The Science of Conjecture: Evidence and Probability before Pascal - cover

The Science of Conjecture

Evidence and Probability before Pascal

By James Franklin

Buy the book

AmazonGETBarnes & NobleGETApple BooksGET

About the book

Before Pascal and Fermat worked out the mathematics of probability in 1654, people still had to reach judgments where certainty was out of reach, and James Franklin sets out to show how they managed it. He looks at the way judges, juries and witch inquisitors weighed evidence, how scientists balanced the arguments for and against a theory, and how merchants tallied shipwrecks to set insurance rates. Some of this reasoning used no numbers at all, as with the legal test of proof beyond a reasonable doubt, while other cases leaned on rough estimates such as gambling odds. The result is a history of rational ways of handling uncertainty across law, commerce, science, logic and philosophy.

Nassim Nicholas Taleb endorsed it, contrasting it with books on probability that wrongly assume the ancients had no notion of the idea.

We hope you love the books people recommend! Just so you know, The CEO Library may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page.

This book has 1 recommendation

Nassim Nicholas Taleb (Flaneur)

As a practitioner of probability, I've had to read many books on the subject. Most are linear combinations of other books and ideas rehashed without real understanding that the idea of probability harks back to the Greek pisteuo (credibility) [and pithanon that led to probabile in latin] and pervaded classical thought. Almost all of these writers made the mistake to think that the ancients were not into probability. And most books such as "Against the Gods" are not even wrong about the notion of probability: odds on coin flips are a mere footnote. Same with current experiments with psychology of probability. If the ancients were not into computable probabilities, it was not because of theology, but because they were not into highly standardized games. They dealt with complex decisions, not merely simplified and purified probability. And they were very sophisticated at it.

The author is both a mathematician and a philosopher, not a philosopher who took a calculus class hence has a shallow idea of combinatorics and feels dominated by the subject, something that plagues the subject of the philosophy of probability. This book stands above, way above the rest: I've never seen a deeper exposition of the subject, as this text covers, in addition to the mathematical bases, the true philosophical origin of the notion of probability.

Finally, Franklin covers matters related to ethics and contract law, such as the works of the medieval thinker Pierre de Jean Olivi, that very few people discuss today.

Get this book on Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Apple Books

See more books recommended by

Nassim Nicholas Taleb

See more books written by

James Franklin

Appears in collections